Program – 23

Beta version

This website is a beta version. It is still being written and built, and has not yet been tested for accessibility.

What is Program – 23?

Program – 23 is the title for the activities organized by a group of people in the field of visual arts. The editorial collective Program – 23 was initiated by Leslie Bauer, Richard Eß, and Maximilian Klawitter in Paris in 2023. They have since organized series of public events that included screenings, publication launches, exhibition displays, talks, and conversations. Program – 23 co-runs the small press publisher named Bauer Verlag. Program – 23's activities rely on collaborations with and contributions by people who work in the cultural field.

How is this website structured?

How to get in touch?

Write to info[at]program-23.org. For detailed information, see the colophon on the bottom of the page.

Are there any Program – 23-news?

No, nothing new at the moment. Next public events are scheduled for spring 2027.

Data sheet 3 of 3

Program – 23: 2025-26

Short description

This program was a screening in three parts. It started in New York on October 16, 2025. The screening showed one video edit, about four hours long. It contained 27 video works or excerpts and live contributions. The "program details" below list each video and state duration, category, short description, authors, and title. While each video played, text on the screen gave basic information and context about it. The whole screening then travelled, with small adaptations, to Vienna in November 2025 and Berlin in January 2026. There was also an extra screening in Basel in March 2026.

Program overview: Program – 23: 2025-26
FormatScreening situation, video
Total durationFrom October 2025 to March 2026
AccessibilityMost of the moving image contributions as part of the screening include written text that must be read for the material to be accessed; all language-based contributions are subtitled in English. In case on-screen reading for longer durations causes you difficulties, you may use the printed Data sheet as an alternative tool for orientation. The lights will remain switched on throughout the screening
Content noticeThe screening includes discussions of colonial violence, discrimination towards sex workers, military violence, police violence, political repression, racism, and suicide. These subjects are addressed analytically or documentarily. There are no explicit depictions of physical violence.
Dates and venues: Program – 23: 2025-26
DateTimeVenueDurationAccessibility
Friday, March 13, 202614:00–18:00distro InfoSpace, Auf dem Wolf 11, 4052 Basel (as part of Make/Sense Assembly, Critical Media Lab, FHNW Basel)not specifieddistro is located on the first floor and can be accessed by elevator.
Thursday, January 15, 202616:00–20:00Stooj, Schillerstraße 6, 10625 Berlin15.–31.01.2026Stooj is on the groundfloor of a residential building. Two stairs are to climb downward.
Tuesday, November 18, 202518:00–22:00Pech, Große Neugasse 44/2, 1040 Vienna18.–23.11.2025Pech is located in a lower ground floor with three stairs to climg downward
Thursday, October 16, 202518:00–22:00The Emily Harvey Foundation, 537 Broadway, New York, NY 1001216.–18.10.2025The Emily Harvey Foundation is on the first flor of a ware house building accessible by elevator.

Data sheet: Program – 23: 2025-26 (PDF, 203 KB) (opens in a new tab)

Data sheet Basel: Program – 23: 2025-26 (PDF, 172 KB) (opens in a new tab)

Program details (reading time about 22 minutes): Program – 23: 2025-26
Time (min) Motive Program (Source-)material
00:00–01:27 a: artistic practice, documented On-the-staircase-footage, ARTCLUB, Vienna, 1994. A clip from the Linda Bilda estate’s stocks. Neither the upstairs ARTCLUB space nor the basement concert are visible. For us, the material works less as historical document than as a thought aid. It offers a symbolic basis for behavioral studies of third wave institutional critical milieus of the 1990s, here Vienna. The camera, compared to Roussopoulos’ interventionist and propagandistic approach, K.ari.n Schneider’s action or attack research, or Bateson’s alleged scientific descriptionist method, is placed at the intersection of auctorial and observational. In the screening, it is mobilized as commentary—on autonomy, critique, and on how rationalization attempts can offer jumping off points for re-mythologization. IC behavioural studies in Vienna of the 1990s, Linda Bilda
01:27–09:03 b: letter/lecture/text/message What Kitnick describes in “Look Who’s Talking” for us acts as good example for cycles of re-mythologizations of rationalization attempts. Antin’s distinction between narrative and story is helpful. References to recent debates around nostalgia, refusal, politicization, and the alleged qualitative decline in artistic expression. The analogy of the taxi cab vs. Uber—introduced as a truncated analysis of capitalism—serves to trace how gestures shift between critique and reaction. The commentary turns to the problem of mediation and immediacy, to the possibility of inhabiting both at once. Is there a form beyond particular artistic examples? Antin, immediacy mediated, Alex Kitnick
09:03–17:25 b: letter/lecture/text/message A contribution from Melinda Cooper based on our inquiry in reaction to Karl Polanyi’s founding myth for the conservative Left’s truncated analysis of capitalism. Helping us to understand why Boltanski/Chiapello and Deleuze/Guattari paved the way for today’s reactionary nostalgia prevalent in institutional critical reruns. Why IC’s obsession with infrastructure and working conditions is what we call re-mythologization of rationalization attempts. And what all that has to do with the naturalization of creativity and care. An attempt to learn from a lacking critique of biologist birth strikes for climate justice, haha, and what La Buse and WFWA could learn from it. Representation vs. redistribution, and why for Fraser (both), Federici, and Kornbluh revolution can only be conservative. On remuneration campaigns and the limits of corporatist demands. A reminder that myths of creativity and care persist at the core of both artistic and reproductive labor. Family values, Melinda Cooper
17:25–21:54 b: letter/lecture/text/message Our perspective on movements like La Buse in France or WFWA in Switzerland is ambivalent. Though they rightly demand fair remuneration for artistic work—often in solidarity with adjacent labor struggles—they remain within the logic of universal basic income, or salaire à vie. Bouteldja critiques this rightfully, although, her reasons might differ from ours. While Friot conceptualized it as PCF member and La Buse influencer. Why do we generally assume union-based approaches to offer anything in cultural sector deeply mythologized. Thought aids on how critique of cultural labor must go beyond redistribution to confront the structural reproduction of, e.g., artistic exceptionalism. “Universal” “basic” “income,” Houria Bouteldja, Bernard Friot, Wissam Xelka
21:54–26:46 b: letter/lecture/text/message Series of transcript excerpts in the form of redacted images. Inserted as commentary on moments where law and art share a gesture: selective contextualization. Mobilized lifes and concepts into predetermined scripts. From the ignored context of a police killing to the re-enchanted taxi cab. Where relevance is naturalized and autonomy returns disguised. Communication may contain a confidential legal services communication. If you are not the intended recipient of this communication, please inform the sender by reply e-mail that the e-mail was not received by the intended recipient, delete all copies of the e-mail from your computer, and destroy any printed copies of the e-mail. Thank you. Redacted images, Vanessa Place
26:46–32:59 c: uses of film in education and communication From a documentary on the 1975 occupation of the Saint-Nizier church in Lyon by local sex workers to denounce their working conditions and police repression. The film helped the protest gain international publicity: the filmed discussions inside the church were broadcast live on a screen outside, drawing public attention. Local media picked up the story, followed by international coverage. Les prostituées de Lyon parlent, Carole Roussopoulos
32:59–35:30 d: colour and plains Colors and plains again, instrumentalized for this screening. Another moment of medium specificity. Episode from an ongoing series. Filming was completed years ago. It remains a video archive that gets reorganized and altered from occasion to occasion. Episodes are reedited or single clips from the archive designated episodes, episodes change numbers and their order is shuffled as needed. Untitled 14, Leslie Bauer
35:30–37:51 d: colour and plains Colors and plains. A rare moment of medium specificity in the program. Together with three other contributions, it represents non-narrativity within the screening as a marker of a Lettrist tradition and focuses on the Vorführ- and Rezeptionssituation (screening situation). Not through disruptive, masculinist, supposedly subversive avant-garde gestures towards the “new.” And without any derogatory relationship with representation from our side. These kinds of contributions can be a break from exerting oneself from a hopefully, either way, absent black-box moment of a continuous narrative. Distance between here to there, Christina Battle
37:51–49:51 New York: d, live
Vienna: d, live
Berlin: b, live
New York, 16.10.2025, Evelyn Plaschg: Partially commissioned interruption in tonal plains, framed by existing tracks. Flute, voice, field recording and synthesizer. Rhythms might begin to run, meet one another, then miss, and strike beside. Not to pin down what was composed, what arises, the performer watches herself or waits for her cue: voice, between layered melodies and spoken inserts (ambition/rap). Composition draws from industrial textures, baroque canon, folk.

Vienna, 18.11.2025, Artjom Astrov: Sounds often stop suddenly, as if they are being caught or redirected. Within the field of rather clicks and taps, it sounds as if objects are being moved or shifted around. Tap-beats that structure the tonal piece have high reverberation tones. Overall, it sounds like a live improvisation with electronic elements, focusing on texture and noise rather than melody or rhythm. A set for a twelve-minute slot, meant as a rehearsal for a concert series. Placed within the screening situation, it could be both a commentary or a piece where strikes and noises become an anti-surface. A contact microphone, bird call drum, and guitar amp are considered instruments in this case.

Berlin, 15.01.2026, Mattin: Mattin’s score for tonight’s Private/Public Intervention, January 15, will be executed within a twelve-minute time frame. Listen to the question, please try to answer it and pass it on. Another question would come up at minute six.
New York: Evelyn Plaschg
Vienna: Artjom Astrov
Berlin: Mattin
49:51–61:51 Vienna: b, live
Berlin: b, live
Vienna, 18.11.2025, Miriam Stoney: To shit where one eats: the question remains whether absolute proximity of the self to the same can allow for “critical distance.” Or whether solidarity remains what it always was and still is: the son, abused by the father, terrorizing his mother, while the sister turns a blind eye, loyalty. It’s a family thing. So-called art is what creates the virtual trenches, the site where lifelong, kinship-like bonds between crippled veterans are formed. Suffering together, floundering in something thicker than water. We all love to mingle around a warming campfire. The ‘new’ spirit of capitalism burns hot and fast, authorship and the artistic subject glows throughout the night while everyone lies sleeping, dreaming. The ground dries out, arid and what’s that: Infrastrukturkritik – just great. Crisp, concise, crass. Conspiracy theories, conservative left-wing populism, externalizing, reformist and apologetic critique were always what kept the self-sadism in your average village running.

Berlin, 15.01.2026, Eric-John Russell: Drawing on Eric-John Russell’s current work on the critique of Meinung and the editorial project Cured Quail. Opinion appears not as harmless plurality, but as a dominant form of certainty: private, inalienable, and strangely resistant to evidence. The contribution functions as commentary on how opinion replaces knowledge while mimicking its authority. From Trump-era media politics to pandemic discourse, opinion circulates as a shortcut to truth. What does it mean when judgment detaches itself from the madness of the masses and why this detachment feels comfortably reassuring.
Vienna: Miriam Stoney
Berlin: Eric-John Russell
00:00–00:00 a: artistic practice, documented Only in New York, 16.10.2025, The video documents the work Sabotage at the closing of the first part exhibition on May 25, 2005, at 6:30 pm at Orchard. A dense fog fills the gallery until visibility fades. Outside firefighters arrive and rush in after a passerby mistook the fog for smoke. The agreed-upon performance involved activating a fog machine at the back of the space, operated by K.ari.n Schneider, along with sound on site by Jutta Koether. It is very releasing for us to see that someone, K.ari.n Schneider, exposed the cathedral of cooperatively organized artist-run exhibition spaces. What we read as a metaphor, making the magic dust visible that covered up the nostalgic reaction that came off the Cologne-NY-axis since the 1990s. A perfect breeding ground for re-mythologizations of alleged rationalizations. Critique of critique, art-as-life, dust to the eyes. The work represents a staged split from the cooperative to show that the collective plan and effort for Orchard had been dismantled from the start. The video is the only record of Schneider and Koether being in the same space at the same time. Sabotage @ Orchard, K.ari.n Schneider
61:51–70:34 a: artistic practice, documented Proposal as path to a solution. A filmed narration of intent—half lecture, half self-analysis—circling the question of field rather than source-subject. Images unfold like prostheses of cognition: representations rehearsing themselves, mediating endlessly between the real and its double. SdA positions itself in a state of cognitive warfare, producing representation against representation, realism against realism. The work asks whether collective image regimes—liberal, anarchist, socialist—remain bound to ownership and subjecthood, or if an alternative can emerge within tactics of collective visual production itself. In the screening, the piece appears as a strategic commercial, a proposal masquerading as method (or vice versa), turning the act of mediation into its own battlefield. We are analyzing a film by SdA (Julia Eichler and Fabian Ginsberg). Explanation Video, SdA (Strategien der Aufstandsbekämpfung/ Counterinsurgency Strategies)
70:34–82:34 b: letter/lecture/text/message Some description along with stories relating the experience of visiting Bernadette Mayer and Philip Good at their home in East Nassau NY, starting circa 2007, where there have been hosted poetries and their students for many years. This is a revised passage from a talk first delivered in Vienna in August 2025, on Bernadette Mayer’s writing as a plastic medium of memory. Everyday and conceptual, rigorous and generous. This part focuses on Mayer’s home/house—a lived space where writing and daily life overlap—alongside reflections on her “Poetry State Forest“ as a model for collective work, where publishing, living, and teaching merge into one ongoing form. Phil and Bernadette‘s House, Roger van Voorhees
82:34–95:05 b: letter/lecture/text/message A contribution from Trevor Stark and Rachel Silveri based on our inquiry in reaction to “Reactionary Art Histories”. Fragments on Hans Sedlmayr and the discipline of art history, combined with recent writing on Artforum and Palestine. Art history’s right wing, reactionary and fascist moments appear not as eccentric deviation but in its best tradition. Of course. The question whether this insight should be used to question artistic practice in its substance and ideological grounding: naturalized as creativity and inherent human faculty and formalized as socially relevant. Or, go on and blame label writers, curators, museum boards, toxic philanthropy, VIP-list-derivate-fascism, or art washing and cooptation. In the best tradition of our discipline, Rachel Silveri, Trevor Stark
95:05–103:36 b: letter/lecture/text/message According to Marx, Proudhon failed to see that economic categories are only abstractions of materialist reality of social relations and are only true insofar as these relationships exist, not the other way around. Thus, he falls into the error of bourgeois economists, who see in these economic categories eternal laws rather. Proudhon, as a result of a mystical reversal, sees abstractions themselves as formulas that have slumbered in the bosom of God since the beginning of the world. Misunderstandings, Letter on Proudhon by Marx to Annenkov, 1846
103:36–108:36 c: uses of film in education and communication Within the screening, Killing Time is instrumentalized for that endlessly repeated anarchist motive—to kill time. Luckily, this is not the author’s aim. Instead, the everyday routine of getting dressed, here, context-specifically the dilemma of finding the right outfit for a suicide. The filmmaker plays herself, not as an artistic subject but simply as someone who wants to finish it up. Killing Time, Fronza Woods
108:36–115:19 c: uses of film in education and communication Scenes of white middle-class nuclear domestic life in San Francisco in 1951. Filmed by Gregory Bateson and Weldon Kees as part of a study on nonverbal communication. Intercut with books on cybernetics, perception, propaganda, and linguistics. Everyday gestures are rendered as data, intimacy becomes diagrams and care sequences, and life systems. Documentation of reproductive processes slips into its abstraction, oscillating between observation and projection. Bateson’s natural-history method was based on microscopic signals that were allegedly considered in the context of macroscopic speech acts. While in other sociovidistic projects the camera operators thought of themselves as invisible, they also forgot to take into account that “Doris” was actually quite annoyed by them. It is therefore more fun to watch the footage as an ethnography of the filmmakers. Weighing the pros and cons of action research (e.g., bio-documentary) and research on symbolic systems (e.g., sociovidistics) remains a fundamental question. Communication and Interaction in Three White Families, Gregory Bateson and Weldon Kees
115:19–120:14 d: colour and plains The contemporary resurgence of Bar Italia, Smerz, and their sonic contemporaries marks not a revival but a meta-operation: the culture industry‘s recursive processing of its own melancholic apparatus. The contribution refers to „individualized introspection as mass movement.” In times of crisis, the culture industry deploys a precise psychological operation. The Strokes‘ and Interpol‘s early-2000s channeling of The Smiths and Slowdive emerged not as organic artistic response but as systematized affect production during recessionary cycles. Today‘s iteration represents the terminal phase of this operation: nostalgia consuming itself. Shoegaze revival, Alyssa Van Denburg, Eric Schmid
120:14–132:14 d: colour and plains Recording and variation from live-on-site-contribution in New York, 16.10.2025. See d-live-slot-entry, min 141:57–153:57. No title, Connor Tomaka
132:14–141:57 d: colour and plains Colors and plains. Within the screening, Kalah acts as a formal interruption, exemplary and already exhausted, a strategy instrumentalized as break. Kalah is a structuralist video by Dóra Maurer in collaboration with Zoltán Jeney. It translates the moves of an ancient board game into sequences of color and tone. Each stone carries pitch and hue, each move triggers its return. Systematic, rule-bound, constructivist. Kalah, Dóra Maurer
141:57–153:57 New York: d, live
Vienna: d, live
Berlin: d, live
New York, 16.10.2025, Connor Tomaka: In Perfect Lives Robert Ashley said of composition that it is “the process of constantly making a decision about when you’re going to update what you’ve just done.” Compositions can be understood as attempt at making tools for continuous recalibration, where the computational system blocks certain paths while pointing toward others, making more clear that the productive conditions surrounding these compositions are ultimately an artifact of physical parameters, forces under constraint, in our case pressure. The interpretive work of mystics and theologians transition into the domain of technician-specialists, trained in deterministic and bayesian methods and increasingly reliant on iterative measurement machines. These systems have enabled an exponential expansion in micro-mechanistic quantification while significantly disempowering any individual’s capacity to understand and traverse the objects they describe. Source recordings of infrastructural materials and human voice that were made at Emily Harvey Foundation, CNMAT in Berkeley, and an apartment in San Francisco are part of a compositional system made with computer hardware.

Vienna, 18.11.2025, Michaela Kisling: KISLING’s composition method, highly informed by digital processing, and meant for contemporary DJ equipment, subtracts and morphs live recorded flute samples by Ilja Gussarov into concrete snippets. KISLING arranges and distorts her tunes on a set of Pioneer CDJs, enriching this musical experience with direct (live on-site) mixing techniques.

Berlin, 15.01.2026, Paul Bonnet: Organized recorded sounds (clarinet, flute, field recordings) and synthesizer sounds by Paul Bonnet. Looped, stretched, and laid out in a way that unfolds them. Approach and eschew narrativity (sequencing, progression) and ambiance (something that is sitting there, maybe just a piece of something larger). Adapting to its acute environment while sticking to the plan. Someone wrote about Paul Bonet (one ‘n’, 1889–1971) that his front and back book cover designs are designed to match the library, not the content they enclose. Later, more industrial designs, some published after his death were based on individual elements from Bonet’s sketches, where the elements are arranged into serial, repetitive patterns not determined by the size or proportion of their base material—more like wallpapers.
New York: Connor Tomaka
Vienna: Michaela Kisling
Berlin: Paul Bonnet
153:57–165:57 New York: b, live
Vienna: b, live
Berlin: b, live
New York, 16.10.2025, Paige K. Bradley: Lecture/reading fragments from Drive It All Over Me (S*I*G Verlag, 2023). Kontextkunst and Dekontextkunst: Between conceptual art’s legacy and selection depending on context, or social prognosis. Depending mostly on the lawyer. Passages turn to the juridical as a system of perception, thinking along identity as alleged material. The figure of the conceptual artist appears as case study: rationalization of practice as labor, re-mythologization of practice as life. Between legacy and collapse, commentary changes form. Within the screening, the reading stages how critique becomes narration, narration myth.

Vienna, 18.11.2025, Shola von Reinhold: Reading from LOTE. White book project: voluntary prevention of an audience (Infrastructuralists prevent a work from its circulation in an “obviously dysfunctional” market/public sphere); Hermia’s Persona/Gesamtkunstwerk: involuntary dispossession of an audience (Infrastructuralists prevent a non-believer’s work from its circulation in “the” public market/ public sphere). In addition to John Latham’s administrative failure, the reading becomes a loose counter-association: to the cycles of remythologization, in which criticism is at risk of becoming self-referential (a hint at a possibility).

Berlin, 15.01.2026, Beatrice Hilke and Vera Lutz: After a short introduction, Beatrice Hilke and Vera Lutz will read from Anna Mendelssohn’s poems. Mendelssohn, along one possible interpretation, invites readers to share aspects of the author’s experiences, while at the same time identifying the readers’ attempts to access her poems with state mechanisms of surveillance and enclosure. For us, the contribution functions as commentary on how law doesn’t only judge actions, but formats readability itself. The reading is mobilized where autonomy returns disguised as relevance, where “context” becomes interrogation, and where writing insists on a form that cannot be processed into evidence.
New York: Kontextkunst, Dekontextkunst, Paige K. Bradley
Vienna: Shola von Reinhold
Berlin: Beatrice Hilke and Vera Lutz on Anna Mendelssohn
165:57–167:27 a: artistic practice, documented A propaganda film from 1988, designed to be screened in the main hall of the former Red Cross headquarters, rented from the Red Cross by the Situationist International, Vienna section (co-founded by Linda Bilda and Ariane Mueller). It was planned to screen the film continuously—day and night, but after 24 hours, the house got squatted by homeless people and the projection was halted. Promotional film, S.I. Vienna section, Ariane Mueller
167:27–192:44 a: artistic practice, documented Video and comment, placed in relation to Alex Kitnick’s reflections on narrative and immediacy and David Antin’s distinction between narrative and story, expose how narrative/context and mediated gesture fold into cycles of rationalization and re-mythologization. Dustan uses the editing-while-filming technique—the record button. Context and narrative collapse into one another. Ratés is the last film in Dustan’s Tristan series (the two Nous-works together and Ratés is a sort of follow-up to Pietà): “We take the car, and I drive him back from Lille to Zurich, he films me, I look half dead, it’s very moving, say one likes that kind of thing, and then he films the road and the trucks with natural special effects. When you’re talented, you’re talented at everything, as Duras said. I like the idea that he filmed one of my films.” Ratés, Guillaume Dustan
192:44–193:49 a: artistic practice, documented Why is the Artist Placement Group (APG) still the most radical initiative by self-described artists to politicize art structurally that comes at least to our minds at this point. Along John Roberts we cannot think of productivist approaches that avoid being pulled into the cycle of not wanting to give up the status as artist-intellectuals completely, while at the same time, not wanting to return to the notion of the artist as independent producer or critic. This is also where the APG failed, and that it comes to mind as best-of-the-bad, is just sad. A filmed sequence of catalog pages, manifestos, and tables—documents outlining John Latham’s cosmology of “flat time” and the APG’s repositioning of the artist. Report of a Surveyor, pp. 15–23, John Latham on APG
193:49–195:27 a: artistic practice, documented The night scene, shot along a waterway in an urban area this past February, is dominated by the repeated chant “It’s Nights Like This,” the chant which is echoed again via the author’s subtitles. The iterative business of eating, digestion, excretion, or reproduction in general, is performed by the three actor’s in a very accessible and entertaining manner. The cart, the supermarkets and love. We imagine the animated cart, they talk of its family, as a baby itself, which we want to throw into the canal to drown. But then decide, the radical everyday, becomes abstraction, as in a Peter Roehr video, and we start to calm down again. Nights Like This adds a note here to the re-mythologization of the everyday. Nights like this 24.02.2025, Cammisa Buerhaus
195:27–195:37 b: letter/lecture/text/message The wording of a leaflet from 1988, designed and distributed by the Situationist International, Vienna section (founded by Linda Bilda and Ariane Mueller) in a contemporary version as interpreted by the LVM Sora. Video reduces space as opposite to drawing and RL but establishes time by placing it in historical time. The original leaflet doubts collectivity but hints to the wish for joint action to create a supportive environment, that enables or produces subjectivity, a task that can be seen in all of Mueller’s and Bilda’s work. Within a recent email conversation: “When something appears as history, you can be sure that someone has an interest in it.” Information, Ariane Mueller, Linda Bilda and SORA
195:37–205:05 b: letter/lecture/text/message Excerpts from Carl Zuckmayer’s Geheimreport (1943/44), written in U.S. exile for the intelligence service OSS. Character portraits of artists, actors, musicians, and writers who remained in Nazi Germany: Benn, Jünger, Gründgens, Rühmann. A document both useful and trivializing—half intelligence file, half literary sketch. Illuminatingly, he writes as part of the report, “More than anywhere else in the world, there was a prevailing view in Germany that artists bore less social responsibility than other people, that they led a life of their own, so to speak, outside the political, social, and economic order, whose foundation and firmament was the timeless world of the arts. (...)” But Zuckmayer is a conservative, focusing on individual responsibility—from this vantage point, contrary to Herbert Marcuse, who, for the same agency, worked on analyzing the economical and political macrostructures of the NS-state, Zuckmayer wrote very subjective microhistories. A letter between Alice Zuckmayer and documentary filmmaker Nina Gladitz will give more context. Macroanalysis vs. Microhistories, Carl Zuckmayer, Alice Zuckmayer, Nina Gladitz
205:05–225:09 c: uses of film in education and communication During the filming of Werner Herzog’s Fitzcarraldo in Peru 1980/81, conflicts arose between Herzog’s film production company Wildlife productions and a group of Peruvian Indigenous Aguaruna peoples. After the community’s council decided not to host and work for Herzog and his film team under the conditions proposed, Herzog called the military on them. Gladitz takes a letter of protest authored by the affected Aguaranas—published in the magazine Pogrom—as her starting point. It reports of a working contract imposed by Herzog’s production company together with the Peruvian military, and violent interventions and arrests. Gladitz shows these events in a polemic against Herzog with the help of the Aguaruna, not simply to denounce Herzog but to confront the structural violence behind the making of an “iconic” film, in open disregard of democratic decision processes. Another of her films from the same year, Zeit des Schweigens und der Dunkelheit (1982), had the working title The Artist’s Responsibility. Land der Bitterkeit und des Stolzes opens with a Jean Renoir quote: “Art that interferes with life for its own sake is obscene.” The parallel that the representation of the Aguaruna community drew between the opera-loving “caoutchouc baron” and “slavemaster” Fitzcarrald and Herzog himself, is commented on by Gladitz in the film: “When the conquest of gold comes at a cost, then the outrage is vast. If the conquest of images comes at a cost, does that increase the value of the images? Is a film review that makes this claim any different from the court reporters of the conquistadors?” Land of bitterness and pride, on Nina Gladitz
225:09–234:02 c: uses of film in education and communication The film follows a campaign to unionize night cleaners. Toilets, offices scrubbed at night, cleaners followed on shift, then in interviews speaking of care work at home—no sleep. In daytime, the boss appears, managing the contracts. Attempts to represent the shifting forces between workers, the Cleaner’s Action Group, and unions collapse into contradictions. Music, vacuuming in slow motion. Within the screening, it is mobilized less as testimony than as a record of instrumentalization itself. Exploitation is visible, but its representation folds workers, activists, filmmakers, and audiences alike into the scene of precarious labor. As part of the sceening this contribution represents a productive instrumentalization of the camera as well as it is a note to ouvselves on the comparison between maintenance/care as labour and art as labour, and its pitfalls. Nightcleaners, Berwick Street Film Collective
234:02–239:37 d: colour and plains Within the screening Latham’s film acts as a formal interruption. A stop motion animated documentation of the production of Latham’s work Film Star, a canvas incorporating books whose pages have been painted in twelve colors. The books can be opened at different pages, therefore the work can exist in different states. In the film, the books open, close and change color. The work is titled Film Star because it’s documented in the film Unedited Material from the Star. Unedited Material from the Star, John Latham

Data sheet 3 of 3

Data sheet 2 of 3

Program – 23: 2023-24

Short description

This program was a series of events mostly realized at À Balzac À Rodin in Paris between September 2023 and June 2024. À Balzac À Rodin is an antiquarian bookstore with a backroom that was used for some of the events. Those included exhibition displays and readings. Parts of the program were realized in other places and included publication launches, conversations, readings, and screenings. Each event as part of the program was a collaboration with different people who work in the field of visual arts. They are listed under "Program details" together with the category, short description, and duration. Downloadable material accompanying or resulting from the events can be accessed under "Program details."

Program overview: Program – 23: 2023-24
FormatMulti-part program
Total durationFrom September 2023 to June 2024
VenueÀ Balzac À Rodin, 14bis Rue de la Grande Chaumière, 75006 Paris
Alternative venues
  • Treize, 24 Rue Moret, 75011 Paris
  • uBu, Karlstraße 6, 76133, Karlsruhe
  • Tonus, 189 Rue Ordener, 75018 Paris
  • *Duuu Radio, Paris
  • City Galerie Wien, Weihburggasse 21, 1010 Vienna
  • di volta in volta, 18 Rue Volta, 75003 Paris
  • Cittipunkt e.V., Brüsseler Str. 36A, 13359 Berlin
AccessibilityFor the main venue, À Balzac À Rodin, there's a narrow spiral staircase to climb. There is no lift. Seating is available. Alcoholic and non-alcoholic beverages are available for free. Alternative venues are mostly accessible from street level with only a small single half-step to climb, of 8 to 15 cm: Treize, in volta di volta, Cittipunkt e.V. Toilets are available at every venue step-free but without accessibility appliances and very small. We are happy to accomodate and improvise for a quite space to rest. Please contact us under info[at]program-23.org if you have any questions.
Content noticeThe works are mostly text-heavy in English language. Often milieu and area-specifically coded. People are on site to assist and happy to translate.

Data sheet: Program – 23: 2023-24 (PDF, 112 KB) (opens in a new tab)

Program details (reading time about 3 minutes): Program – 23: 2023-24
Category Short description Authorship Duration One-day occation Alt. venue Downloads
Exhibition display Annotated statement of case. A juridical document that expresses the intent of its authors to disclose their involvement in the use, repetition, and promotion of the acknowledgement of a special status of visual arts; inces- tuous solidarity; negligence, etc. Status, in revision. Vanessa Place 21.09.– 30.09.2023 21.09.2023, 19:00– 22:00 not specified
Exhibition display Propositions, statements, a sequence of two-sentence panels: until the expected description is found by trial to be attained. Works will be brought to Paris, or printed out on site. Jonas Raam 16.10.– 25.10.2023 16.10.2023, 19:00– 22:00 not specified
Exhibition display Presentations, mediations, and justifications for an artistic practice in public. In conjunction with the publication of one of three versions of a collection of texts including seven sonnets, “7 Flints;” seven poems, “7 Djinn;” and the description of seven exhibitions, “7 Things.” Roger van Voorhees 07.05.– 18.05.2024 03.05.2024; 07.05.2024; 11.05.2024; 15.05.2024; 21.05.2024 03.05.2024: uBu, Karlstraße 6, 76133 Karlsruhe; 07.05.2024: À Balzac À Rodin, 14bis Rue de la Grande Chaumière, 75006 Paris; 11.05.2024: Tonus, 189 Rue Ordener, 75018 Paris; 15.05.2024: City Galerie Wien, Weihburggasse 21, 1010 Vienna; 21.05.2024: *Duuu Radio
Screening, live broadcast Frankfurt Marathon en direct: On Sun- day 29th of October we will broadcast live from the tail end of the 40th Frank- furt marathon, testing a decentralized directing method to merge three camera perspectives in real time. With an interlude from UGC Ciné Cité Les Halles. Nina Könnemann; Live-Camera: Verena Buttmann, Nina Könnemann, Kari Leigh Rosenfeld; Broadcasting: Sofus Keiding-Agger; additional camera: Leslie Bauer 29.10.2023 29.10.2023 15:15– 17:00 Treize, 24 Rue Moret, 75011 Paris
Text-/ Publication- invitation, Comment One claim about derived intentionality is that it is the intention with which an act is performed that bestows the intentionality on the physical phenomena. Examples of un- intentional intentionality are brought forward to argue that intention, be that of an author or a recipient, is not necessa- ry for intentionality. Unintentional Intentionality, Iulia Nistor From Sept. 2023 to June 2024 13.10.2023, 19:00 not specified
Text-/ Publication- invitation, Comment The booklet includes a 50-shilling note as well as descrip- tive short sentences with different intentions. Money is not only a quantitative figure, but also expresses the qualitative relation of production, and therefore is not a mere sign. In portions of text, a narrative basis, mood, or sceneries emerge. Whoever runs out of money, dies. 50 Schilling, S.I.G. Verlag, Ulla Rossek From Sept. 2023 to June 2024 not specified not specified
Text-/ Publication- invitation, Comment On the usefulness to oppose discourses of justification, led by artists and other agents in the field of art, with a materialist conception of the history of cultural institutions. On abolitionism as a counter tendency to corporatist and formalist approaches of emancipation. Cultural Abolitionisms, 2021, 2023 / Des Abolitionnismes Culturels, 2021, 2023, Bauer Verlag, Guillaume Maraud From Sept. 2023 to June 2024 15.06.2024, 18:30 Cittipunkt e.V., Brüsseler Str. 36A, 13359 Berlin
Text-/ Publication- invitation, Comment Publicness and forms of communication with regard to the futility of an artistic practice within demarcated corporatist consensus groupings. Attempts at an understanding that is contrary to the parameters that define a supposed public. A conversation on site and a recording device for archiving or distribution. Strategien der Aufstandsbekämpfung / Counterinsurgency Strategies, AKV Berlin, SdA From Sept. 2023 to June 2024 30.05.2024 di volta in volta, 18 Rue Volta, 75003 Paris
Text-/ Publication- invitation, Comment On reflections on individuation, leading to ontologies in which the party has always already begun (no primal scenes), no separation, no relationality but constitutive relationality. (Epistemological) realisms that postulate the inseparability of being and knowing: on a time that breaks with the scientific and political modernisms of sequentiality. What Flashes Up: Theological-Political- Scientific Fragments, Karen Barad From Sept. 2023 to June 2024 not specified not specified

Event text/description (reading time about 3 minutes)

17.09.2023

The dissolution of dichotomies is pending. Radical-rationalists (1) are confident that after Madonna, Lady Gaga means progress. Radical-retreaters (2) do not have either of them on their evaluation spreadsheet, the needle on their measuring device doesn't move in the slightest. The decision of what is considered within the spectrum of the considerable often works through excluding the non-considerable by naming it (1) rather than not naming it (2).A cake from a single ingredient, water, is water (3).

The ones with an official certificate are allowed to retire (1.1), they glance back toward disciplinary societies, with visions of revolutionary communism and a permanent general strike. The ones without a certificate compensate by forming sibling-hoods to protect and approve each other (1.2), they acknowledge societies of control, with visions of postmodern intersectionality and fair payment. (1) don't shit where they eat; (2) do; (3) eat their own shit and it's delicious because it has everything they know and want, including self-reflection.

A home where authentically grown values and organically evolved community norms replace deliberate acts of will and social justice. A house locked from the inside, where pre-existing opinions govern and creativity only emerges spontaneously. Where artistic practice forms alliances with reproductive labor and irrelevant ideas are revived and updated. Together they evolve into ever-expanding and open-ended chosen families. As if the concept of the canteen and the elderly home did not exist.

In spring there was the theater as a model, this fall there is the elderly home and the canteen. The fire under the stove will be put out and friends extinguished. Problem – 23 refers to a time when autonomous thought would have caused surprise and intuition was not imagined, let alone individual expression.

14.03.2023

We are confronted with a decision between (1) radical rationalization of artistic practice, which would mean fair payment and the revolutionary destruction of the autonomy-of-the-economy, and (2) radical retreat into a serious artistic practice, which would mean the exit from the logic of reward and the individualized false promise of an outside to the autonomy-of-the-economy. Or, put differently, unconditional love must be either paid for, or free for all. Both approaches exist and are equally attractive. As a consequence of the impossibility of the fulfillment of their respective claims: simply, the ability of (1) 'political action' or (2) a 'serious practice,' the application of either of these two ideals leads to the withdrawal from the field of visual arts and its institutions. Legitimately we mutate into hated enemies, as we continue to work in this field.

Program – 23 begins with the screening of one video file over the course of three evenings at a theater, here replaced with an arbitrary location. It is composed of an over-length feature film that is repeatedly interrupted for the screening of a reoccurring long shot, adaptations of written text, and audio-visual contributions based on moments of mediation. The program refers to a time when a central narrative would have caused surprise and separating walls were not imagined, let alone their subsequent collapse. The lights remain switched on and the bar open. Any conditions that might invite the audience into a self-enclosed fictional world separate from the evenings’ circumstances are avoided.

Our professional milieu is a comfortable home and breeding ground for the possessive individual. At this point, solidarity among artists—members of a naturally corrupt family—seems downright inappropriate. Their identification with and claim for a special status makes it impossible to distinguish moments of solidarity from moments of corruption. We can only hope that the walls of this family home will collapse; (1) will have left the collapsing house in advance, only to be run over by a car on the streets, (2) survives traumatized and subsequently suffers an endless death from slowly inserting a sword into their own wombs, (3) is covered by rubble and dies instantly, without realizing what just happened.

Leslie Bauer, Richard Eß, Maximilian Klawitter

Data sheet 2 of 3

Data sheet 1 of 3

Program – 23: 2023

Short description

This program was a screening in three parts. It ran in Paris between March and May 2023. The screening showed one video edit, about nine hours long. This edit was divided by three and one part each screened on the three dates indicated. It contained 32 video works or excerpts. The "program details" below list each video and state its duration, category, authors, and title. One reoccuring long film was cut up and integrated into the edit. Some of the contributions were texts produced as audio-visual material for the screening. The categories were divided and attributed included: ...

Program overview: Program – 23: 2023
Format3-part screening program, one video file
Total running time video9:15 hours
AccessibilityStep-free entrance and accessible toilet. Films are shown with English subtitles. Seating available.
Content noticeOne film contains flashing lights
Dates and venues: Program – 23: 2023
DateTimeRunning timeVenueAccessibility
Wednesday, March 29, 2023From 19:00 to 23:30, screening starts 20:003:15 hoursLe Saint-Gervais, 96 rue Vieille du Temple, 75003 Parisno steps
Tuesday, April 18, 2023From 19:00 to 23:30, screening starts 20:002:45 hoursCafé des arts, Cité internationale des arts, 18 rue de l’Hôtel de ville, 75004
Paris
Wheelchair friendly entrance
Tuesday, May 16, 2023From 19:00 to 23:30, screening starts 20:003:15 hoursCafé des arts, Cité internationale des arts, 18 rue de l’Hôtel de ville, 75004
Paris
not specified

Data sheet: Program – 23: 2023 (PDF, 111 KB) (opens in a new tab)

Program details (reading time about 2 minutes): Program – 23: 2023
Screening Column Contribution
1/3 A Visible Adversaries, reoccurring one shot, 1977, min 00:20–03:40
1/3 B (a) The Victories of Art are Bought with a Loss of Character, Monsieur Roubignoles, 2012/2023, min 15:00–35:00; (b) Lamentations on Golf 1+2, Monsieur Roubignoles, 2015, 15:00 min
1/3 C a) Agent Kelly and all that is the Case, Roger van Voorhees, 2011, min 01:00–05:53, 08:53–09:57, 11:20–15:31; (b) 9th Annual Experimental Lecture, MM Serra, 2018, min 38:50–55:42
1/3 D Theresa Hak Kyung Cha’s Manuscript for Performance sur Vampyr, Program – 23, 1976/2023, 01:00 min
1/3 E Press Release for Tinted Spirit at Project Native Informant London 2022, Dozie Kanu, 2022, 11:55 min
1/3 F (a) Adrian Williams and Filip Caranica at Inge Mahn and Nora Schultz, 2017, 20:55 min; (b) Vanessa Place on The Trout, 2019/2023, 05:00 min
1/3 G Eros + Massacre, over-length feature film, 1969, min 73:00–144:00
2/3 A Visible Adversaries, reoccurring one shot, 1977, min 00:20–03:40
2/3 B Cultural Abolitionisms, 2021, 2023, Guillaume Maraud, 2021/2023, 29:00 min
2/3 C Senses, Talking, How to Jill Johnston, Megan Francis Sullivan, 2020, min 05:22–09:24,13:04–23:19, 43:40–46:40
2/3 D Moved by a Huge Crain, Program – 23, 1999/2023, 16:45 min
2/3 E (a) Scene Sketch 1 01-06, Siw Umsonst, 2018, 01:30 min; Scene Sketch 2 01-04, Siw Umsonst, 2019, 02:30 min; (b) KÜHLPSALTER (klittern), after G.J., 24 March, 1970, BRUCH, 2023, 4:45 min; (c) A Rigid Column, Connor Tomaka, 2023, 21:00 min
2/3 F (a) Post Time, Dana Munro, video, 2019, 02:50 min; (b) Performance documentation Soccer, Annette Wehrmann, 1991, 19:30 min
2/3 G Eros + Massacre, over-length feature film, 1969, min 145:00–216:00
3/3 A Visible Adversaries, reoccurring one shot, 1977, min 00:20–03:40
3/3 B (a) The Victories of Art are Bought with a Loss of Character, Monsieur Roubignoles, 2012/2023, min 00:00–15:00; (b) Radical rationalization vs. Radical retreat, Program – 23, 2023, 01:00 min
3/3 C In-House Letters, Self-evident Legibility, Nick Mauss, Ken Okiishi on Hanne Darboven, 2017, min 02:38–04:51, 12:54–20:28, 63:02–72:04
3/3 D Letter Exchange, EBM and Bing, Program – 23,1939/1950/2023, 06:00 min
3/3 E (a) Old life, Michaela Kisling, 2022, 20:10 min; (b) A Trailer for Roheisen & Hutwetter: System of Science, First Part, the Phenomenology of Spirit; Part II: Hegel’s Preface, or: the Gimmick, 2023, Sophia Rohwetter, Sophia Eisenhut, 2023, 04:00 min; (c) Untitled, A E Brandt, 2018, 01:10 min
3/3 F (a) J.S.’s Apartment, exhibition/apartment walk through, MM Serra, 1990, 08:30 min; (b) The Supporters (philanthropists’ gestures), screening version, Eva Barto, 2023, 12:00 min; (c) Sabotage @ 47 Orchard, K.ari.n Schneider, 2005, 3:45 min
3/3 G Eros + Massacre, over-length feature film, 1969, min 00:00–72:00

Event text/description (reading time about 2 minutes)

14.03.2023

We are confronted with a decision between (1) radical rationalization of artistic practice, which would mean fair payment and the revolutionary destruction of the autonomy-of-the-economy, and (2) radical retreat into a serious artistic practice, which would mean the exit from the logic of reward and the individualized false promise of an outside to the autonomy-of-the-economy.Or, put differently, unconditional love must be either paid for, or free for all. Both approaches exist and are equally attractive. As a consequence of the impossibility of the fulfillment of their respective claims: simply, the ability of (1) 'political action' or (2) a 'serious practice,' the application of either of these two ideals leads to the withdrawal from the field of visual arts and its institutions. Legitimately we mutate into hated enemies, as we continue to work in this field.

Program – 23 begins with the screening of one video file over the course of three evenings at a theater, here replaced with an arbitrary location. It is composed of an over-length feature film that is repeatedly interrupted for the screening of a reoccurring long shot, adaptations of written text, and audio-visual contributions based on moments of mediation. The program refers to a time when a central narrative would have caused surprise and separating walls were not imagined, let alone their subsequent collapse. The lights remain switched on and the bar open. Any conditions that might invite the audience into a self-enclosed fictional world separate from the evenings’ circumstances are avoided.

Our professional milieu is a comfortable home and breeding ground for the possessive individual. At this point, solidarity among artists—members of a naturally corrupt family—seems downright inappropriate. Their identification with and claim for a special status makes it impossible to distinguish moments of solidarity from moments of corruption. We can only hope that the walls of this family home will collapse; (1) will have left the collapsing house in advance, only to be run over by a car on the streets, (2) survives traumatized and subsequently suffers an endless death from slowly inserting a sword into their own wombs, (3) is covered by rubble and dies instantly, without realizing what just happened.

Leslie Bauer, Richard Eß, Maximilian Klawitter

Data sheet 1 of 3